Forty chemical manufacturing CEOs express concerns over rail merger to President Trump
The Breakdown
Forty CEOs representing the U.S. chemical manufacturing sector have sent an urgent letter to President Trump, voicing unified concern about the proposed merger between Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern—two of the nation’s largest freight railroads. Their primary fear: this consolidation could inflame already acute competition and reliability issues in the U.S. rail sector, undermining the supply chain stability and the global competitiveness of domestic chemical manufacturers. The move would put nearly half of U.S. rail traffic under the control of a single entity, raising red flags about escalating service disruptions, higher transportation costs, and the threat of additional mergers creating a near-monopoly environment.
Analyst View
U.S. chemical manufacturers rely on dependable, cost-competitive logistics to deliver raw materials and finished goods efficiently nationwide. With the two mega-railroads poised to merge, the industry faces unprecedented uncertainty around transportation reliability, pricing leverage, and operational flexibility. While scale can streamline some processes, extreme concentration often introduces systemic risk: fewer routes, fewer service providers, and higher dependence on a single supply chain node.
Competitive alternatives for rail transport are already limited. As four rail giants currently control over 90% of U.S. volume, further consolidation will tip the balance—diminishing choice for shippers and amplifying the risk of both cost inflation and long-term supply chain bottlenecks. Historical precedent points to heightened disruption: past rail mergers have resulted in marked service reliability drops, increased shipping costs, and operational delays that ripple from the manufacturer through to end-market customers.
The regulatory environment is now a critical focal point. With the Surface Transportation Board tasked to review this merger, chemical sector leaders are pushing for strict enforcement of competition standards to ensure rail access remains viable, rates don’t skyrocket, and the operating landscape does not favor a de facto monopoly. The outcome will have direct consequences for industry growth outlooks, capital investment deliberations, and the ability to meet evolving customer and regulatory demands.
Navigating the Signals
B2B leaders in specialty chemicals and polymers must anticipate reduced leverage in negotiating transport contracts, potential cost surges, and increased risk of supply chain interruptions if the merger proceeds unmitigated. Beyond immediate pricing and service concerns, a super-railroad’s control could constrict innovation in logistical solutions, shift cost structures, and challenge customer commitment to long-term contracts—especially for those with “just-in-time” or customized logistics needs.
Business planners should now closely examine internal resilience to logistics disruptions and pressure-test alternative carrier scenarios. Questions to pose internally: Do we have a clear view on transport dependencies by site and product line? Can we rapidly shift logistics partners or routes when disruption strikes? Are our customer agreements robust against upstream rail service failures or rate hikes? Leaders should be alert to the downstream effects on their entire value chain, from procurement through distribution partnerships.
What’s Next?
Breakthrough Marketing Technology helps specialty chemical and polymer B2B leaders proactively size and manage the risk landscape by:
- Mapping logistics and supply vulnerabilities against your revenue and customer base to identify single points of risk.
- Quantifying the downstream financial impacts of limited transportation alternatives and cost volatility.
- Benchmarking your market and operational exposure versus peer competitors to isolate strategic differentiators.
- Arming leadership teams with data-driven scenarios and regulatory tracking to support informed decision making.
By translating market complexity into actionable insights, we enable executive teams to protect continuity while capturing new opportunities in a shifting value chain environment. Prepare for both regulatory outcomes—and position your business to thrive, regardless of the external landscape.
Source
Understand Your Risk. Seize Your Opportunity.
Take the Breakthrough Market Uncertainty Assessment Guide to pinpoint what’s holding your growth back, and what can accelerate it.
